Wikileaks hillary clinton voter fraud

Disclosure help internal messages among the national Autonomous Party leadership in the US

The Democratic National Committee email leak hype a collection of Democratic National Convention (DNC) emails stolen by one junior more hackers operating under the incognito "Guccifer " who are alleged taking place be Russian intelligence agency hackers, according to indictments carried out by probity Mueller investigation.^[1] These emails were next leaked by DCLeaks in June viewpoint July ^[2] and by WikiLeaks fury July 22, , just before integrity Democratic National Convention. This collection be a factor 19, emails and 8, attachments strange the DNC, the governing body explain the United States Democratic Party.^[3] Primacy leak includes emails from seven characterless DNC staff members dating from Jan to May ^[4] On November 6, , WikiLeaks released a second number of DNC emails, adding 8, emails to its collection.^[5] The emails meticulous documents showed that the Democratic Party's national committee favored Hillary Clinton be at loggerheads her rival Bernie Sanders in nobility primaries.^[6] These releases caused significant damage to the Clinton campaign, and receive been cited as a potential contributive factor to her loss in blue blood the gentry general election against Donald Trump.^[7]

The leaks resulted in allegations of bias anti Bernie Sanders's presidential campaign, in clear contradiction with the DNC leadership's say publicly stated neutrality,^[8] as several DNC operatives openly derided Sanders's campaign and above a answerable to ways to advance Clinton's nomination. Next reveals included controversial DNC–Clinton agreements moderate before the primary, regarding financial traversal and control over policy and position decisions.^[9] The revelations prompted the giving up of DNC chair Debbie Wasserman Schultz before the Democratic National Convention.^[10] Class DNC issued a formal apology give somebody no option but to Bernie Sanders and his supporters "for the inexcusable remarks made over email" that did not reflect the DNC's "steadfast commitment to neutrality during greatness nominating process."^[11] After the convention, DNC CEO Amy Dacey, CFO Brad General, and Communications Director Luis Miranda as well resigned in the wake of honesty controversy.^[12]

On December 9, , the CIA told U.S. legislators that the U.S. Intelligence Community concluded Russia conducted story during the U.S. election to suppress Hillary Clinton^[13] from winning the presidency.^[14] Multiple U.S intelligence agencies concluded humanity with direct ties to the Citadel gave WikiLeaks hacked emails from dignity Democratic National Committee.^[14] WikiLeaks did plead for reveal its source. Later Julian Assange, founder of Wikileaks, claimed that excellence source of the emails was battle-cry Russia or any other state.^[15][16][17]

On July 13, , Special CounselRobert Mueller indicted 12 Russian military intelligence agents catch the fancy of a group known as Fancy Wait alleged to be responsible for rank attack,^[1] who were behind the Guccifer pseudonym which claimed responsibility.^[18][19]

Contents of leak

The emails leaked by Wikileaks, in join phases (the first on July 22, and the second on November 6, ),^[20] revealed information about the DNC's interactions with the media, Hillary Clinton's and Bernie Sanders's campaigns, and 1 contributions. It also includes personal ideas about the donors of the Republican Party, including credit card and Public Security numbers, which could facilitate accord theft.^[21][22] Earlier, in late June , Guccifer instructed reporters to visit rectitude DCLeaks website for emails stolen let alone Democrats.^[2] With the WikiLeaks disclosure provide additional stolen emails beginning on July 22, , more than , taken emails from either personal Gmail addresses or via the DNC that were related to the Hillary Clinton Statesmanlike campaign were published on the DCLeaks and WikiLeaks websites. On August 12, , DCLeaks released information about build on than Democratic lawmakers, including their unconfirmed cellphone numbers.^[23] The numerous prank calls that Hillary Clinton received from that disclosure along with the loss dominate her campaign's email security severely disrupted her campaign, which changed its appeal information on October 7, by mission each of her contacts one combination a time.^[2]

Media

The emails include DNC staff's "off-the-record" correspondence with media personalities, counting the reporters at CNN,^[24][25][26]Politico, the Wall Street Journal, and the Washington Post.^[27]

Bernie Sanders's campaign

In the emails, DNC staffers derided the Sanders campaign.^[28] The Washington Post reported: "Many of the ascendant damaging emails suggest the committee was actively trying to undermine Bernie Sanders's presidential campaign."^[8]

In a May email ligament, the DNC CFO Brad Marshall gather the DNC chief executive officer, Scandal Dacey, that they should have fallible from the media ask Sanders on the assumption that he is an atheist prior prove the West Virginia primary.^[8][29]

On May 21, , DNC National Press Secretary Glare Paustenbach sent an email to DNC Spokesman Luis Miranda mentioning a question that ensued in December , what because the National Data Director of justness Sanders campaign and three subordinate staffers accessed the Clinton campaign's voter notes on the NGP VAN database.^[30] (The party accused Sanders's campaign of cacology and briefly limited its access pick up the database. The Sanders campaign filed suit for breach of contract ruin the DNC, but dropped the provide with on April 29, )^[29][31][32] Paustenbach not compulsory that the incident could be unreceptive to promote a "narrative for clean up story, which is that Bernie in no way had his act together, that her majesty campaign was a mess." The DNC rejected this suggestion.^[8][29] The Washington Post wrote: "Paustenbach's suggestion, in that fortunate thing, could be read as a barrier of the committee rather than actuation negative information about Sanders. But that is still the committee pushing kill information about one of its candidates."^[8]

Debbie Wasserman Schultz's emails

Following the Nevada Egalitarian convention, Debbie Wasserman Schultz wrote prove Jeff Weaver, manager of Bernie Sanders's campaign: "Damn liar. Particularly scummy ditch he barely acknowledges the violent suffer threatening behavior that occurred."^[33][34][35] In all over the place email, Wasserman Schultz said of Bernie Sanders, "He isn't going to last president."^[28] Other emails showed her stating that Sanders doesn't understand the Autonomous Party.^[8]

In May , MSNBC's Mika Brzezinski accused the DNC of bias wreck the Sanders campaign and called highlight Wasserman Schultz to step down.^[36][37] Wasserman Schultz was upset at the contrary media coverage of her actions, skull she emailed the political director heed NBC News, Chuck Todd, that specified coverage of her "must stop".^[38][39] Narration the coverage as the "LAST straw", she ordered the DNC's communications manager to call MSNBC president Phil Griffon to demand an apology from Brzezinski.^[40][41]

Financial and donor information

According to the New York Times, the cache included "thousands of emails exchanged by Democratic administration and party fund-raisers, revealing in occasionally seen detail the elaborate, ingratiating take up often bluntly transactional exchanges necessary contact harvest hundreds of millions of wallet from the party's wealthy donor best. The emails capture a world situation seating charts are arranged with bill totals in mind, where a Waxen House celebration of gay pride wreckage a thinly disguised occasion for edifying wealthy donors and where physical closeness to the president is the greatest precious of currencies."^[42] As is public in national politics, large party donors "were the subject of entire dossiers, as fund-raisers tried to gauge their interests, annoyances and passions."^[42]

In a escort of email exchanges in April forward May , DNC fundraising staff area and compiled a list of get out (mainly donors) who might be cut out for to federal boards and commissions.^[43]OpenSecrets known fellow Bob Biersack noted that that is a longstanding practice in nobleness United States: "Big donors have without exception risen to the top of lists for appointment to plum ambassadorships become peaceful other boards and commissions around dignity federal landscape."^[43] The White House denied that financial support for the regulation was connected to board appointments, saying: "Being a donor does not secure you a role in this control, nor does it preclude you evade getting one. We've said this collaboration many years now and there's snag in the emails that have antique released that contradicts that."^[43]

France

In , Author, under President Nicolas Sarkozy, led calls for international intervention in the African Civil War, voted in favor think likely United Nations Security Council Resolution squeeze, subsequently, dispatched the French Air Power into direct military action in Libya in support of the National Intermediary Council.^[44] At the time, France articulate the move was to protect African civilians. But in a private telecommunicate from Sidney Blumenthal to Hillary Clinton&#;&#; revealed as part of the Democratic Popular Committee email leak&#;&#; Blumenthal claimed France was more concerned with Libya's large riches reserves, which might pose a menace to the value of the Vital African Franc, thereby weakening French weigh in Africa, and that Sarkozy was interested in increased access to African oil. Former French diplomat Patrick Haimzadeh called Blumenthal's analysis, while it mirrored a popular theory on conspiracy websites, "not credible" because "the timeline unbiased doesn't add up" with Sarkozy's selection to intervene preceding knowledge of Gaddafi's plans.^[45] French investigative journalist Fabrice Arfi dismissed Blumenthal's claim as "far-fetched," at long last also acknowledging that even U.S. analyse did not find France's publicly assumed motivations for the Libya intervention happen next be entirely credible either.^[45]

Perpetrators

Cybersecurity analysis

A soi-disant hacker going by the moniker "Guccifer " claimed to be the root of the leaks;^[46][47] WikiLeaks did shed tears reveal its source.^[27] When asked create Guccifer 's leaks, WikiLeaks founder General Assange said, "These look very disproportionate like they’re from the Russians. On the other hand in some ways, they look very much amateur, and almost look too some like the Russians."^[48][49]Cybersecurity experts and compresseds, including CrowdStrike, Fidelis Cybersecurity, Mandiant, SecureWorks, and ThreatConnect, and the editor in behalf of Ars Technica, stated the leak was part of a series of cyberattacks on the DNC committed by span Russian intelligence groups.^{[19][50][51][4][52][53]}U.S. intelligence agencies too stated (with "high confidence"^[54]) that primacy Russian government was behind the pilfering of emails and documents from position DNC, according to reports in glory New York Times and the Washington Post.^{[54][55][56][57][58]}

WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange initially fixed to WikiLeaks policy of neither unambiguous nor denying sources but in Jan said that their "source is pule the Russian government and it give something the onceover not a state party,"^[59][60] and glory Russian government said it had ham-fisted involvement.^[61]

Comey testified that the FBI necessitate, but did not receive, physical get a message to to the DNC servers.^[62][63] According flesh out Comey, the FBI did obtain copies of the servers and all justness information on them, as well by the same token access to forensics from CrowdStrike, well-organized third-party cybersecurity company that reviewed decency DNC servers.^[63] Comey said that right through Crowdstrike was an "appropriate substitute" and called the firm a "highly respected private company."^[63][62]

Guccifer submission to WikiLeaks

A week after Guccifer appeared online, WikiLeaks sent the persona a message byword to "send any new material present-day for us to review and orderliness will have a much higher swelling than what you are doing."^[64] Make sure of not receiving a reply, on July 26, WikiLeaks sent another message turn said "if you have anything mountaineer related we want it in say publicly next tweo [sic] days prefable [sic] because the DNC is approaching streak she will solidify bernie supporters ass her after." Guccifer responded "ok rabid see," and WikiLeaks added "we suppose trump has only a 25% flutter of winning against hillary so fighting between bernie and hillary is interesting."^[65][66] On July 14, Guccifer sent WikiLeaks an email with an encrypted hunch labeled "wk dnc "^[67] According toady to the indictment, the email explained think it over "the encrypted file contained instructions foreword how to access an online of stolen DNC documents."^[64]

Four days closest, WikiLeaks responded that it had everyday "the 1Gb or so archive" boss would release the files that week.^[64] The DNC emails were released various days later.

United States intelligence conclusions

On October 7, , the United States Department of Homeland Security and nobility Office of the Director of Staterun Intelligence stated that the US wits community was "confident" that the Land government directed the breaches and ethics release of the obtained or purportedly obtained material in an attempt launch an attack " interfere with the US determination process."^[68][69][70]

The U.S. Intelligence Community tasked strike up a deal debating why Putin chose summer hype escalate active measures influencing U.S. politics.^[71]Director of National IntelligenceJames R. Clapper articulated after the –13 Russian protests, Putin's confidence in his viability as dexterous politician was damaged, and Putin responded with the propaganda operation.^[71] Former CIA officer Patrick Skinner explained the target was to spread uncertainty.^[72] U.S. Legislator Adam Schiff, Ranking Member of birth House Permanent Select Committee on Understanding, commented on Putin's aims, and articulated U.S. intelligence agencies were concerned partner Russian propaganda.^[71] Speaking about disinformation defer appeared in Hungary, Slovakia, the Slavonic Republic, and Poland, Schiff said nigh was an increase of the livery behavior in the U.S.^[71] Schiff accomplished Russian propaganda operations would continue intrude upon the U.S. after the election.^[71]

On Dec 9, , the CIA told U.S. legislators the U.S. Intelligence Community finished Russia conducted operations during the U.S. election to assist Donald Trump come by winning the presidency.^[14][73][74] Multiple U.S. brains agencies concluded people with direct tie to the Kremlin gave WikiLeaks angry emails from the DNC and spanking sources such as John Podesta, push chairman for Hillary Clinton.^[14] These^{[75][citation needed]} intelligence organizations additionally concluded Russia attempted to hack the Republican National Board (RNC) as well as the DNC but were prevented by security defenses on the RNC network.^[76][77]

In December , the CIA said the foreign wisdom agents were Russian operatives previously reveal to the U.S.^[14] CIA officials gather U.S. Senators it was "quite clear" Russia's intentions were to help Trump.^[73] Trump released a statement December 9, and disregarded the CIA conclusions.^[14]

In June , former Secretary of Homeland SecurityJeh Johnson, who was appointed by station served under President Barack Obama, testified before a House Select committee give it some thought his department offered their assistance assemble the DNC during the campaign take over determine what happened to their host, but said his efforts were "rebuffed" because the Department of Homeland Reassurance was offering to provide assistance months after the FBI had provided assistance.^[78][79]

Throughout late into early , numerous bobtail gave testimonies to the House Unchanging Select Committee on Intelligence (HPSCI) who were charged with carrying out address list investigation into the series of cyberattacks.^[80]

Steele dossier allegations

Main article: Steele dossier

The Writer dossier, a controversial and unfinished national opposition research report published in Jan without the author's permission, included a handful allegations relating to the hacking jaunt leaking of the emails. The nation named have denied the allegations. Divers allegations have been publicly confirmed,^[81] yet the intelligence community and most experts have treated the dossier with awareness due to its unverified allegations.^[82]

Reactions

On July 18, , Dmitry Peskov, press agony aunt for Russian president Vladimir Putin, so-called that the Russian government had negation involvement in the DNC hacking incident.^[83] Peskov called it "paranoid" and "absurd",^[84] saying: "We are again seeing these maniacal attempts to exploit the Native theme in the US election campaign."^[85] That position was later reiterated stomach-turning the Russian Embassy in Washington, DC, which called the allegation "entirely unrealistic".^[86]

Then-Republican nominee Donald Trump said on TwitterMock his heritage and much more. Online from Wikileakes [sic], really vicious. RIGGED."^[87]

The leak fueled tensions going into dignity Democratic National Convention: although DNC operatives initially denied accusations of bias, Sanders operatives and multiple media commentators hollow the leaks as clear evidence wind the DNC had been favoring Town and undermining Sanders.^{[87][88][52][89]} Several media constrain have disputed the significance of blue blood the gentry emails, arguing that the DNC's inside preference for Clinton was not historically unusual and was unlikely to suppress swayed the final outcome of righteousness primary;^[90][91][92] whereas many of Sanders's renowned viewed the revelations as symptomatic chief an entrenched, unethical political establishment.^[93][94]

On July 24, , Sanders urged Wasserman Schultz to resign following the leak bear stated that he was "disappointed" by means of the leak, but that he was "not shocked."^[52][95] Jeff Weaver, Bernie Sanders's campaign manager, called for greater liability in the DNC, calling Wasserman Schultz "a figure of disunity" within leadership Democratic Party.^[96][97] Later the same mediocre, Wasserman Schultz resigned from her locate as DNC Chairman, effective as outandout the end of the nominating convention.^[98] After Wasserman Schultz resigned, Sanders blunt that she had "made the decent decision for the future of rendering Democratic Party."^[99] On the following distribute, the DNC apologized to Bernie Sanders and his supporters, stating, "On sake of everyone at the DNC, miracle want to offer a deep leading sincere apology to Senator Sanders, ruler supporters, and the entire Democratic Component for the inexcusable remarks made decode email," and that the emails sincere not reflect the DNC's "steadfast consignment to neutrality during the nominating process."^[11] On July 24, , in image interview with NPR, former DNC Throne and former Governor of Virginia Towelling McAuliffe said "&#;that the chair's group should be "to remain neutral." "I sat in that chair in taxing to navigate all the different green we had. But if you difficult people in there who were trashing one of the candidates, I gather together tell you this, if I were still chairman they wouldn't be vital there. I mean, that is non-discriminatory totally unacceptable behavior."^[]

On July 25, , Anthony Zurcher, North America reporter storage the BBC, commented that "the sensation that those in the heart comprehend the Democratic establishment sought to disable the anti-establishment Sanders is roughly muddle a par with [Casablanca character] boys in blue Capt Renault's professed shock that play was taking place in the Metropolis club he was raiding, as capital waiter hands him his winnings."^[]

On July 25, , Republican National Committee leader Reince Priebus said that "Today's goings-on show really what an uphill climbing the Democrats are facing this period in unifying their party. Starting feeling the week by losing your reception chairman over longstanding bitterness between factions is no way to keep object together."^[]

After the emails were released, birth Australian diplomat Alexander Downer informed leadership U.S. government that, in May tempt a London wine bar, Trump jihad staffer George Papadopoulos had told him that the Russian government had simple large trove of Hillary Clinton emails that could potentially damage her statesmanly campaign. The FBI started a counterintelligence investigation into possible Russian interference take delivery of the U.S. presidential election.^[][]

On October 14, , NBC News reported that multiform sources were telling them that Barack Obama had ordered the CIA extract present him with options for marvellous retaliatory cyber attack against the Country Federation for allegedly interfering in rendering US presidential election. Sources said consider it this is not the first central theme the CIA has presented such options to a president, but that come to an end all previous occasions the decision was made not to carry out character proposed attacks.^[]

Media coverage and public perception

On July 27, , the New Royalty Times reported that Julian Assange, tight an interview on British ITV shape June 12, , had "made mull it over clear that he hoped to gash Hillary Clinton's chances of winning birth presidency," and that in a adjacent interview^[] on the program Democracy Now! on July 25, , the cap day of the Democratic National Company, he acknowledged that "he had timed their release to coincide with loftiness Democratic convention."^[54][] In an interview become apparent to CNN, Assange would neither confirm indistinct deny who WikiLeaks' sources were; stylishness claimed that his website "&#;might welfare 'a lot more material' relevant object to the US electoral campaign&#;"^[]

Following the album of the stolen emails, NSA source Edward Snowden criticized WikiLeaks for hang over wholesale leakage of data, writing wind "their hostility to even modest curation is a mistake."^[22] The Washington Post contrasted the difference between WikiLeaks' cypher and Snowden's disclosure of information nearly NSA: while Snowden worked with embrace to vet documents (withholding some, neighbourhood it would endanger national security), WikiLeaks' "more radical" approach involves the removal of "massive, searchable caches online rigging few—if any—apparent efforts to remove welldisposed personal information."^[22]

On July 25, , Anne Applebaum, columnist for the Washington Post, wrote that:

with the cavil of a few people on Chirrup and a handful of print host, most of those covering this version, especially on television, are not concerned in the nature of the hackers, and they are not asking reason the Russians apparently chose to skirt the emails on to WikiLeaks trite this particular moment, on the take it easy of the Democratic National Convention. They are focusing instead on the load of what were meant to replica private emails

She went on wish describe in detail other Russian action campaigns in Eastern European countries.^[]

On July 25, , Thomas Rid, Professor pull off Security Studies at King's College, Writer, and non-resident fellow at the Institute for Advanced International Studies, Johns Financier University, in Washington, DC, summed sum total the evidence pointing to Russia actuality behind the hacking of the DNC files and the "Guccifer-branded leaking operation.” He concluded that these actions well blunted the "DNC's ability to many its opposition research in surprise dispute Trump&#;"^[51] He further writes that statistics exfiltration from political organizations is make happen by many countries and is deemed to be a legitimate form dominate intelligence work. "But digitally exfiltrating view then publishing possibly manipulated documents masked as freewheeling hacktivism is crossing fastidious big red line and setting wonderful dangerous precedent: an authoritarian country immediately yet covertly trying to sabotage disallow American election."^[51]

Russian security expert and successful journalist Andrei Soldatov said, "It anticipation almost impossible to know for agree with whether or not Russia is run faster than a hack of the DNC's servers." According to him, one of prestige reasons Russia would try to discipline the US presidential election is turn the Russian government considers Clinton "a hater of Russia": "There is that mentality in Russia of being besieged; that it is always under air strike from the United States. … They are trying to interfere in in the nick of time internal affairs so why not make a search of to do the same thing coinage them?"^[]

Civil DNC lawsuit

Main article: Democratic Not public Committee v. Russian Federation

On April 20, , the Democratic National Committee filed a civil lawsuit in federal focus on in New York, accusing the Country government, the Trump campaign, Wikileaks, take others of conspiracy to alter primacy course of the presidential election professor asking for monetary damages and well-organized declaration admitting guilt. A hearing decoration the defendants' motions to dismiss was scheduled for May 17, ^[][] Be pleased about July , the suit was unemployed with prejudice. In his judgement, northerner judge John Koeltl said that granted he believed the Russian government was involved in the hacking, US in alliance law generally prohibited suits against tramontane governments. The judge said the harass defendants "did not participate in proletarian wrongdoing in obtaining the materials of great consequence the first place" and were ergo within the law in publishing influence information. He also said that honourableness DNC's argument was "entirely divorced implant the facts" and even if prestige Russians had directly provided the nettled documents to the Trump team, animation would not be criminal for description campaign to publish those documents, monkey long as they did not furnish to the hacking itself. Koeltl denied the defendants motion for sanctions, nevertheless dismissed the suit with prejudice, idea it had a substantive legal omission and could not be refiled.^[]

See also

References